回测过拟合的概率

Discussion in 'Model and Algorithm' started by novaavon, Nov 21, 2013.

  1. The Probability of Back-Test Overfitting

    http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2326253

    Abstract:

    Most firms and portfolio managers rely on back-tests (or historical simulations of performance) to select investment strategies and allocate them capital. Standard statistical techniques designed to prevent regression over-fitting, such as hold-out, tend to be unreliable and inaccurate in the context of investment back-tests. We propose a framework that estimates the probability of back-test over-fitting (PBO) specifically in the context of investment simulations, through a numerical method that we call combinatorially symmetric cross-validation (CSCV). We show that CSCV produces accurate estimates of the probability that a particular back-test is over-fit.
     
  2. 其实只要心中不去追求超常绩效,就能避开绝大多数的过拟。
    反之,只要存在强烈渴望,想要搞出一个牛B朝天的系统,不管多么小心谨慎最终总是会过拟。
    因为做的过程中,无过拟的普通绩效系统被直接忽略了。然后在一堆超常绩效系统中寻找,想要找到一个看起来没有过拟的NB系统,但其实只是还没明白哪里过拟而已。如果找不到就会继续找下去。
     
  3. 方向错了。:)


    ---------------------
    感谢novaavon大侠分享!
    文章看了,可能看论文多了的关系,这篇文章和参考文献都没发现什么亮点,但是对于正在学习进步的人可能会有些帮助。
     
  4. 能否请ku大指点一下,具体怎么个错法?

     
  5. 稍后请查收邮件。:)