老范的交易者性格测试不错

Discussion in 'Behaviour and Cognition' started by rypan, Nov 13, 2010.

  1. I'm an administrative trader.
     
  2. 如果愿意,你也可以把你的测试报告翻译一下
     
  3. 社會責任型投資 (Socially Responsible Investment), 或稱可持續型與社會責任投資(Sustainable & Responsible Investment) 均簡稱為SRI. SRI 顧名思義屬於一種投資活動, 但相對於傳統投資活動僅著重於財務的報酬, SRI 具有更為積極的意義. 在ㄧ般的共識下, SRI 包含三個層面的追求目標, 也就是所謂的三重底限(Triple Bottom Line)

    1. 財務型的報酬
    2. 社會(Social)或倫理(Ethical)上的目標, 與
    3. 環境保護(Environmental)上的目標

    財務上的績效是短期而具體的, 但是社會與環保上的目標是長期而不顯著的; SRI 的興起反映出投資人在追求短期財務報酬的同時, 也積極的希望自己所投資的公司能夠善盡環境保護與企業公民的社會責任. 換言之, 代表社會大眾對於企業行為採取更嚴格的監督標準, 以及對於企業改善社會的能力有更高的期望.
    由於 SRI 同時考量三重底限的目標, 投資人願意犧牲部分的財務績效, 以達成整體社會更高的效率與公平. 舉例而言, 今天投資人可以選擇投資兩個基金, 其中第ㄧ個投資軍火與煙草等公司, 而另外ㄧ個基金投資符合 SRI 標準的公司, 此時即使前ㄧ個基金可以配發每年15%的現金股利, 而 SRI 基金只能配發7%的股利, 但投資人基於 SRI 的理念, 也許願意投資第二個基金, 以換取後者在環保與社會上較長期而無形的貢獻, 如後者投資的公司也許承諾每年增加雇用10%的員工, 固定將公司盈餘的5%捐出協助社區發展, 或是採用符合最高環保標準的生產製程等等. 因此投資人在SRI 追求的是整體的社會報酬, 而不僅是財務上的績效.

    從歐美的發展實務上, 可以觀察到許多 SRI 基金的投資績效, 其實並不遜於股市大盤或是特定類型的投資標的, 證明 SRI 不僅在概念上具有吸引力, 在實際的操作上也可以完全符合投資人的需求.
     
  4. I am a Detailed Trader.
     
  5. it seemed i'm a Planning Trader.

    what's that surposed to mean ?
     
  6. I'm an administrative trader,too.
     
  7. 其实这种测试忽略了一个问题。
    那就是反身性。
    所以如果稳定盈利,风格还未确定的,最好别做。
     
  8. 做了一下:
    Thank you for taking the Tharp Trader Test!
    Self-knowledge is the first step to improvement.
    You are a StrategicTrader

    You are quick to see market patterns, which allows you to take advantage of them. You are an avid thinker; therefore, understanding trading will come easier to you than to your peers. Your great drive to achieve your goals will help you be a great trader, if that is important to you.

    One of Your Trading Strengths - You are quick to see patterns with the ability to rapidly

    One of Your Trading Challenges - You have a strong desire to be right so you might want to work on perfecting systems rather than trading them.
     
  9. YOU ARE AN
    INDEPENDENT
    TRADER
    You endeavor to develop a logical explanation for how the markets work. You value knowledge above all else. As a result, you'll be generating new ideas about the market or trying to disprove the ideas that you learn from others constantly. You are very independent, unconventional, and original.

    One of Your Trading Strengths - You like the challenge of sorting out market conditions and the intellectual stimulation of developing and planning low-risk trading ideas.

    One of Your Trading Challenges - You may reject or abandon workable systems if the logic isn't clear because you don't understand the systems boundaries ahead of time.
     
  10. You are a StrategicTrader

    You are quick to see market patterns, which allows you to take advantage of them. You are an avid thinker; therefore, understanding trading will come easier to you than to your peers. Your great drive to achieve your goals will help you be a great trader, if that is important to you.

    One of Your Trading Strengths - You are quick to see patterns with the ability to rapidly

    One of Your Trading Challenges - You have a strong desire to be right so you might want to work on perfecting systems rather than trading them.


    The above underlined is somehow incorrect. I observe market with great respect, and believe system doesn't have to be perfect to make money. :)
     
  11. StrategicTrader不少啊

    可以理解
     
  12. YOU ARE A DETAILED TRADER
    我也去测试了一次
     
  13. You are a Detailed Trader
     
  14. I am a Detailed Trader. :confused:
     
  15. 同学们可以把分析的Detail贴出来分享,大家一同肖习肖习
     
  16. I am a Detailed Trader,too.

    Detailed Trader Type

    As a Trader... you tend to earn your success by being thorough, methodical, systematic,organized, and dependable. You are also realistic and responsible as long as things
    make sense for you. You have two of the three qualities that are necessary for trading success (i.e., you make decisions based on logic and analysis and you are decisive,
    orderly and do things sequentially).

    YOU are very quiet and serious. You tend to earn your success by being thorough,methodical, systematic, organized, and dependable. You are also realistic and
    responsible as long as things make sense for you. You have two of the three qualities that are necessary for trading success (i.e., you make decisions based on logic and
    analysis and you are decisive, orderly and do things sequentially). Thus, if you are willing to commit yourself, you probably will be quite successful as a trader. You may need
    some help seeing the big picture, which is necessary for trading success.

    You have a tremendous internal store of facts that you like to analyze. But you also tend to have trouble seeing anything that is different from your internal picture of the world.
    As a result, one of your biggest challenges is that you have a distinct idea of what is right and you feel it is your duty to defend that. This can be a real problem in trading the
    markets where being independent and a nonconformist are important.

    Because you like to analyze, you will tend to identify the facts, label them and then categorize the information so that it makes sense to you. You work best with clearly
    stated objectives and procedures although you should be vigilant about who’s directives you are following in the trading arena, or you may find yourself working on the wrong things.

    Trading can be a solitary and lonely business; however, this is something that might actually suit you because you do not mind working on your own.
    You enjoy thinking things through before sharing them with others.

    Example Trader Warren Buffett
    Our model of the detailed trader is Warren Buffett. Buffett’s analytical habits and love of detail are renowned.He once said, “If you want to be a successful investor, then
    you have to know every detail of every listed stock.” And when someone said, “but there are over 7000 listed stocks,” Buffett responded, “Start with the As.”
    He has been listed as one of the five richest men in the world. Buffett achieved his status of being called the world’s greatest investor when he paired up with Strategic Trader, Charlie Munger.
     
  17. 由于这些年来的发现,我做成结论,认为有一些交易类型存在。有些类型是天生的交易人,其它人则需要经过一段磨练,才能娴熟执行交易的重要事项。

    我们发展出萨普交易人测验(TharpT rader Test),把交易人分成15 种不同的类型。我针对每一类型,找了一个初型分配给那类交易人,然后列出该类交易人的强项和面对的挑战。请上www.tharptradertest.com,找出你是哪类交易人。用几分钟
    的时间回答一份问卷,你会知道自己所属的类型,以及需要做些什么事才会成功。现在就做,只要花五分钟。把你的交易人类型写在这里。

    有大约半数的交易人类型,成功的潜能都很高,其中以策略型交易人最为自然,爱玩型交易人最不自然。把这些名词凑在一起很有趣,因为我的工作之一,是找到适合每一类的初型交易人。为自然倾向于成功的交易人类型,寻找好典范,这件事相当简单。保罗•都德•琼斯(Paul Tudor Jones)就是策略型交易人的好例子。

    不过,不是那么自然就能成功的交易人类型,我能挑选的例子很少,因为那种人根本不会成为好交易人。针对爱玩型交易人这一类,我最后选上的是星巴克(Starbucks)执行长。他肯定很爱玩,而由于他投资自己的公司,所以我可以称他是成功的投资人/交易人。不过,他肯定不是琼斯,而且永远不可能是。

    知道了自己是属于哪一种交易人类型之后,来看看全部15个类型,以及每一个类型特有的一些挑战。

    1.策略型交易人:这类交易人有很好的成功机会,但是(1)可能没有看到情绪性的错误,(2)倾向于追求完美,以及(3)强烈渴望把事情做对。

    2.规划型交易人:这类交易人也有极佳的成功机会。你的主要挑战是渴望获得激情,以及需要把事情做对。你可能很容易就对交易感到乏味,而做出一些事情来减轻这种感觉,结果反而限制了利润。

    3.详细型交易人:详细型交易人有不错的成功机会,但你可能见树不见林,太注重你所做事情的细节,以致错过了大局势。

    4.行政管理型交易人:你可能对自己过于吹毛求疵,却没能看清就在眼前的错误。此外,受到压力时,你可能质疑自己对交易的投入不够多,因为你不觉得交易成绩令人满意。行政管理型交易人也有不错的成功机会。

    5.助导型交易人:这类交易人的成功机会高于平均水平。不过,你可能在逻辑上和观念上遇到问题,因为你总是在寻找新东西。此外,你可能需要外人肯定你的观念、信念和系统。

    6.创新型交易人:你的成功机会高于平均水平。不过,你可能需要外人肯定你所做的每一件事,而且强烈需要一位指导人。此外,由于你的情绪反应,觉得某个系统找你麻烦,可能倾向于过早放弃那个好系统。

    7.价值驱动型交易人:你交易成功的机会高于平均水平,但觉得必须按照自己的方式去做事。此外,纪律、跟催、注意细节,始终是你的困扰。你也可能发现交易枯燥无味,而做出一些能让自己觉得兴奋的事情。

    8.独立型交易人:你凡事注重逻辑,很容易排拒运作得不错的一些系统,因为你不了解它们的运作道理。此外,交易可能占满你的时间,使你与人隔绝,不相往来。虽然如此,如果你专心致志,成功的机会不错。

    以下七种类型的交易人,想要在交易的竞技场上出人头地,则困难得多。
    9.社会责任型交易人。
    10.冲动型交易人。
    11.支持型交易人。
    12.准确型交易人。
    13.艺术型交易人。
    14.爱玩型交易人。
    15.冒险型交易人。

    就算你是属于后面这七类的交易人,交易也并非不可能的任务,但你必须更加卖力,投入更多。